Coaching Role Play - How to coach an executive who is hesitant in making decision

Guiding an executive who craves validation towards confident decision-making involves helping them build self-assurance, focus on internal validation, and trust their abilities. Before we go to the coaching conversation role play, here’s how you can approach this:

1. Identify the Root Cause

• Ask Reflective Questions: Explore why they crave validation. Is it fear of failure, imposter syndrome, or past experiences?

• Challenge Limiting Beliefs: Help them identify and reframe negative thought patterns, such as equating external approval with success.

2. Encourage Self-Awareness

• Strength Inventory: Guide them to reflect on their achievements, skills, and successful decisions to reinforce their capability.

• Decision-Making Style Assessment: Analyze their decision-making habits to identify strengths and areas for improvement.

3. Teach Decision-Making Frameworks

• Structured Approaches: Introduce models like SWOT analysis or the 80/20 rule to reduce emotional dependency on others’ opinions.

• Risk Assessment: Help them weigh the risks and rewards logically, reducing the need for external reassurance.

4. Promote Internal Validation

• Celebrate Wins: Encourage them to acknowledge their successes without waiting for external recognition.

• Set Personal Metrics: Help them define success based on their values and priorities instead of others’ standards.

5. Cultivate Self-Trust

• Small Decisions First: Encourage them to make and own small decisions without seeking input, gradually building confidence.

• Reflect on Outcomes: Have them review past decisions to identify instances where their intuition was correct.

6. Provide Tools for Resilience

• Visualization Exercises: Encourage them to imagine scenarios where they lead with confidence.

• Mindfulness or Coaching Practices: Help them stay present and reduce anxiety about external validation.

7. Give Balanced Feedback

• Validate Their Strengths: Offer genuine acknowledgment of their efforts to wean them off seeking it elsewhere.

• Constructive Criticism: Provide actionable insights that empower them rather than foster dependence.

Here’s a role-play scenario to help guide an executive toward confident decision-making.

Scenario #1:

The executive, Chris, is deciding whether to approve a new project proposal. They’ve reviewed the details but are hesitant to commit without validation from their team or board.

Coach’s Dialogue

Step 1: Clarify the Situation

Coach: “Chris, tell me about this project. What excites you about it, and what concerns you?”

Chris: “It’s innovative, and I believe it could significantly improve our market position. But I’m unsure if I’ve considered everything—what if I’m missing a critical risk? I want to hear what others think first.”

Step 2: Shift to Self-Trust

Coach: “It sounds like you’ve put a lot of thought into this. Let’s break it down. Based on your experience and the data you’ve reviewed, what’s your gut telling you?”

Chris: “Honestly, I feel it’s the right move. The numbers align, and I can see how it would benefit the company. But I keep second-guessing myself.”

Coach: “Second-guessing is natural, especially for someone who cares deeply about outcomes. Let’s pause and reflect—can you think of a past decision you made that turned out well, even without full approval from others?”

Chris: “Yes, when I pushed for the new CRM system last year. It was risky, but it’s paying off now.”

Step 3: Strengthen Internal Validation

Coach: “Exactly! That decision came from your insight and expertise. This project seems to align with your strong track record. What’s one action you could take today to move forward confidently without needing external validation?”

Chris: “I could draft a memo outlining the key risks and benefits for myself, just to solidify my reasoning.”

Coach: “Great! And how will you celebrate taking this decisive step?”

Chris: “Maybe I’ll schedule a team huddle to share the decision, not to seek approval but to present my vision clearly.”

Step 4: Empower Ownership

Coach: “That’s a strong move. Let’s commit to this approach. Remember, as a leader, trusting yourself is as important as trusting your team. Every decision won’t be perfect, but this confidence will inspire others. How do you feel about this strategy?”

Chris: “I feel more in control. I like the idea of focusing on my own reasoning instead of waiting for consensus.”

Takeaway Exercise:

• Reflection Prompt: “Each evening this week, write down one decision you made confidently and its impact.”

• Confidence Builder: Ask Chris to identify 3 personal values or principles to guide their future decisions.

Let’s adapt the scenario for a technology industry executive who is hesitant to greenlight a new product feature due to concerns about team approval and market reception.

Scenario #2: Tech Executive Role-Play

Jamie, a VP of Product Development, is deciding whether to proceed with a groundbreaking AI feature. While Jamie sees the feature as innovative, they worry about potential resistance from the engineering team and doubts about market readiness.

Coach’s Dialogue

Step 1: Clarify the Challenge

Coach: “Jamie, tell me more about this AI feature. What makes it stand out to you, and what’s holding you back?”

Jamie: “It could revolutionize how our users interact with the platform. But the engineering team raised some concerns about timelines, and I’m not sure the market is ready for it. I want to run it by leadership again to get their input before committing.”

Step 2: Anchor in Expertise

Coach: “That’s a big opportunity. Let’s take a step back. What’s your unique perspective as VP of Product Development? Why do you believe in this feature?”

Jamie: “I’ve been tracking AI trends, and our competitors are moving in this direction. Our user research also shows demand for more intuitive interactions. I just want to make sure it’s the right time.”

Coach: “Your perspective is grounded in data and vision—two of your greatest strengths. Instead of focusing on the perfect timing, what would happen if you trusted your expertise and took a calculated risk?”

Jamie: “I suppose we’d get ahead of the competition and could iterate if needed.”

Step 3: Use a Decision Framework

Coach: “Exactly. Let’s apply a simple framework. If you greenlight this feature, what are the top 3 benefits to the company?”

Jamie: 1. “Increased user engagement through AI-driven interactions.”

2. “A competitive edge in the market.”

3. “Strengthened reputation as innovators.”

Coach: “And the top 3 risks?”

Jamie: 1. “Delays in development.”

2. “Higher initial costs.”

3. “Potential lukewarm adoption at first.”

Coach: “Great analysis. What steps can you take to mitigate the biggest risk—development delays?”

Jamie: “I could allocate additional resources and create a phased rollout to manage the timeline better.”

Step 4: Encourage Ownership and Action

Coach: “You’ve outlined clear benefits, risks, and solutions. What’s one step you can take right now to move forward confidently?”

Jamie: “I’ll draft a pitch for leadership with a phased rollout plan and present it as a decision, not a question.”

Coach: “That’s a confident move! How will you measure success after the launch?”

Jamie: “By tracking user engagement metrics and gathering feedback during the beta phase.”

Follow-Up Actions:

• Reflection Exercise: Jamie keeps a “Decision Journal” to log outcomes and lessons from bold decisions.

• Leadership Practice: Jamie begins weekly team check-ins where decisions are discussed transparently, fostering mutual trust and reducing the need for validation.

-------------

Summary

Based on the role-play, a coach should develop the following skills and qualities to effectively guide an executive toward confident decision-making:

1. Active Listening

• Pay close attention to the executive’s words, emotions, and underlying concerns.

• Validate their perspective without judgment, creating a safe space for exploration.

• Example from Role-Play: Asking Jamie why they believe in the AI feature and listening to both their excitement and hesitation.

2. Questioning and Clarification

• Use open-ended, reflective questions to help the executive uncover their own insights.

• Challenge assumptions without being confrontational.

• Example: Asking, “What makes this feature stand out to you?” and “What steps can you take to mitigate the biggest risk?”

3. Confidence-Building

• Help the executive recognize and leverage their strengths, experiences, and expertise.

• Remind them of past successes to build self-trust.

• Example: Highlighting Jamie’s track record with user research and trend analysis to validate their instincts.

4. Decision-Making Frameworks

• Teach tools like SWOT analysis, cost-benefit analysis, or phased rollouts to add structure to decision-making.

• Simplify complex choices into manageable steps.

• Example: Breaking down the benefits, risks, and mitigation strategies for the AI feature.

5. Reframing and Perspective Shifting

• Encourage a shift from external validation to internal confidence by focusing on data, expertise, and values.

• Help the executive reframe fear of failure as an opportunity for learning.

• Example: Guiding Jamie to trust their vision and present the rollout plan as a decisive action, not a question.

6. Empowerment and Accountability

• Encourage the executive to take ownership of their decisions.

• Offer follow-up actions or exercises to reinforce their growth.

• Example: Suggesting Jamie log their decisions in a journal to track outcomes and lessons learned.

7. Emotional Intelligence

• Recognize the executive’s fears and motivations, addressing them with empathy.

• Balance encouragement with constructive feedback.

• Example: Validating Jamie’s hesitation while redirecting their focus to their expertise and logical analysis.

8. Adaptability

• Tailor coaching methods to the executive’s personality, industry, and specific challenges.

• Be flexible in switching between guidance, support, and challenge.

• Example: Adjusting the role-play to fit Jamie’s technology industry context and leadership role.

Key Takeaway

A successful coach fosters self-awareness, confidence, and autonomy in their clients by listening actively, asking insightful questions, and equipping them with practical tools. By doing so, the executive transitions from seeking validation to making decisions with clarity and conviction.